Dutch Borrower B.V.” (“the taxpayer”), part of an international group, deducted interest and commitment fees under intra-group credit facilities for 2012/2013 to 2016/2017. It paid a fixed margin over Euribor on drawn amounts and a commitment fee on the full facility, including undrawn headroom. The tax authority held that the remuneration exceeded an arm’s length level under Section 8b and reduced the deductions. By interim judgment, the Court accepted a total cost approach per facility and the borrower’s BB+ and BBB ratings.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The taxpayer argued that no arm’s length range had been established, that too few comparables were used and that the search was wrongly limited to Western Europe. | The tax authority argued that the combined interest and commitment fee per facility exceeded arm’s length levels, justifying the adjustments. | The Court held that the total cost approach must be applied ex ante using Euribor forward rates, without hindsight. With few close comparables, the bond most favourable to the taxpayer applies, not the median. |
It claimed a liquidity adjustment for privately placed loans and country adjustments for the debtor’s country of establishment and operations, based on a regression study. | It contended that substantive defects meant the required returns had not been filed, and sought reversal of the burden of proof. | Liquidity and country adjustments were rejected. The burden of proof was reversed, as the benchmark was deficient and no contemporaneous creditworthiness analysis existed. |
The Court of Appeal upheld the adjustments for facilities 1, 3a, 5 and 7bn, set aside the one for facility 3 and further reduced that for 7bn. Pricing was tested at inception on total cost, and the absence of contemporaneous creditworthiness analyses contributed to reversal of the burden of proof.

