The case: In Kloeckner Desma Machinery Pvt. Ltd. (AYs 2012-13 and 2013-14), decided on 17 July 2026, the TPO used the 5% royalty rate on domestic sales as a CUP to test the 8% royalty paid on exports. Royalty adjustments were Rs. 19,18,458 and Rs. 19,67,641.
The ruling: The royalty adjustments were deleted, because the domestic rate was not a proper comparable for export royalty. Commission adjustments of Rs. 67,77,799 and Rs. 37,07,151 were sent back, because the TPO had not shown that the database agreements he relied on were comparable.
A CUP must compare like with like. Different markets can mean different arm's length rates.

