The case: In WhatsApp Application Services Pvt. Ltd. (ITA No. 832/HYD/2024, AY 2020-21), the TPO marked up the value of RSUs and ESOPs that the parent granted to the Indian entity's employees.
The ruling: The Tribunal deleted the adjustment. The Indian entity had neither incurred nor booked the cost. Under Rule 10B(1)(e)(i), the cost base must reflect costs actually "incurred", and a hypothetical benefit cannot be marked up.
Captive service providers should confirm whether the parent cross-charges share-based pay, because that decides whether it belongs in the cost base.

