The case: In LANXESS India Pvt. Ltd. (ITA No. 6627/Mum/2025, AY 2022-23), the TPO set the arm's length price of Production Technology, Safety and Environment (PTSE) services from AEs at nil. That gave an adjustment of Rs. 61.22 crore.
The ruling: The facts were materially the same as in earlier years, where the Tribunal had accepted the services and deleted similar adjustments. The Revenue showed no distinguishing facts, so the earlier rulings were binding and the adjustment was deleted.
For recurring intra-group charges, a consistent file of evidence year after year is the strongest defence.

