• Transactions

    Employee threshold

    Turnover threshold

    Economic adjustment

    Global Tax

    Hard-to-Value Intangibles (HTVI)

    OECD Framework

    Multinational Enterprises (MNEs)

    APMA

    APA

Bombay HC: No Fresh Scrutiny or TPO Reference on a Section 170A Modified Return While Assessment Is Pending

Bombay HC: No Fresh Scrutiny or TPO Reference on a Section 170A Modified Return While Assessment Is Pending

Bombay HC: No Fresh Scrutiny or TPO Reference on a Section 170A Modified Return While Assessment Is Pending

Thomson Reuters International Services Private Limited (“the assessee”) provides IT and ITeS services to its group AEs. For AY 2022-23, the TPO proposed adjustments on IT services, ITeS and interest on receivables, and the assessee objected to the draft order before the DRP. After the NCLT approved a merger with an appointed date of 1 September 2019, it filed a modified return under Section 170A declaring the same income. The Revenue then issued fresh notices under Sections 143(2) and 92CA(2), reopening the TP exercise for the same year.


Assessee’s Contentions

Revenue’s Contentions

Court’s Judgement

The assessee contended that the assessment was still pending when the modified return was filed, so Section 170A(2)(b) applied and the modified return had to be taken into account within the pending assessment.

The Revenue argued that the original return had been replaced by the modified return and had become non-est.

The High Court held that a draft order under Section 144C(1) does not conclude the assessment, as DRP proceedings are part of it. Section 170A(2)(b) therefore applied and operates within the pending assessment.

It submitted that the Revenue could not start a second, parallel scrutiny and transfer pricing proceeding for the same year through further notices under Sections 142(1) and 92D(3).

The Revenue relied on Section 170A(3), contending that it preserved the general machinery of the Act, including the power to issue a notice under Section 143(2).

Section 170A(3) could not confer jurisdiction otherwise absent. As the Section 143(2) notice was without jurisdiction, the Section 92CA(2) notice founded on it fell too. Both notices and all consequential proceedings were quashed.

Bombay HC held that, as assessment proceedings were pending, the modified return filed under Section 170A after the merger had to be dealt with inside those proceedings. The fresh Section 143(2) notice and the second TPO reference for the same year were quashed.

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Transfer Pricing at Arm’s Length. Value Aligned, Globally Delivered.

  • Contact

  • +91 93609 91001

  • info@nexusprice.org

  • Willingdon Crescent, 4th Floor,#6/2, Dr. S.S.Badrinath Road, Nungambakkam, Chennai 600 006

©2025 NexusPrice. All rights reserved

©2025 NexusPrice. All rights reserved