Repsol Sinopec Brasil SA (“the taxpayer”), an oil and gas company holding 25% of the BM-S-9 and 10% of the Albacora Leste consortia, deducted in 2018 charter costs paid to its related parties Guara B.V. and Agri B.V. for four FPSO platforms. It benchmarked them under the PIC method (Brazil’s CUP equivalent) using the average ratio of daily charter rate to replacement value of four FPSOs chartered from unrelated owners. The tax authority recalculated the benchmark for contract term and for an owner’s return of 3.33% based on ROACE.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The taxpayer contended that neither the contract-term adjustment nor the ROACE adjustment is an adjustment authorised by the transfer pricing rules, and that its charter prices were below the PIC benchmark, so no adjustment was required. | The tax authority found that the comparable contracts had initial terms of seven to nine years against twenty years for the controlled contracts, and that the return expected by platform owners had been ignored. It adjusted the daily rate using an annuity formula. | The Superior Chamber held that adjustments under Articles 9 and 10 of IN 1,312/2012 are restricted: an adjustment not listed in Article 9 must reflect the production costs of the good, service or right and address only differences between the items compared. |
The taxpayer argued that ROACE was taken from consolidated accounts covering all activities of multinational groups, not only FPSO charters, and was computed from years other than the year under review. | The authority applied the weighted average ROACE of SBM, MODEC, Saipem and Teekay for 2011 to 2018, being 3.33%, as the rate of return expected by the platform owners. | The Chamber held that ROACE measures the profitability of a whole business and imports profits from unlike activities without legal basis. The 2011-2018 period did not match the year tested, and rates ranging from -25.82% to +15.10% showed the index was unsuitable. |
CARF’s Superior Chamber heard the special appeal only on the ROACE index and unanimously dismissed it, so the annulment of the adjustment stands. ROACE taken from the consolidated results of whole groups for 2011-2018 was held unsuitable as a comparability adjustment to the PIC benchmark.

