• Transactions

    Employee threshold

    Turnover threshold

    Economic adjustment

    Global Tax

    Hard-to-Value Intangibles (HTVI)

    OECD Framework

    Multinational Enterprises (MNEs)

    APMA

    APA

US Tax Court: Rule 143(g) Does Not Apply to Expert Declarations Filed in a Pretrial Discovery Dispute

US Tax Court: Rule 143(g) Does Not Apply to Expert Declarations Filed in a Pretrial Discovery Dispute

US Tax Court: Rule 143(g) Does Not Apply to Expert Declarations Filed in a Pretrial Discovery Dispute

Airbnb, Inc. & Subsidiaries (“the taxpayer”) operates an online marketplace for travel accommodation. In a section 482 case, the Commissioner determined an income increase of about USD 4.2 billion for resources, capabilities and rights made available on 31 December 2013 to an affiliate registered in Ireland and tax resident in Jersey. In a discovery dispute over review of the taxpayer’s source code, the Commissioner filed two declarations from a software expert with 48 years of experience. The taxpayer moved to strike them.

Assessee’s Contentions

Revenue’s Contentions

Court’s Judgement

The taxpayer argued that the declarations were in substance expert witness reports that did not satisfy Tax Court Rule 143(g), and that they offered legal opinions and advocacy contrary to Federal Rule of Evidence 702.

The Commissioner argued that Rule 143 and Rule 702 do not apply to declarations filed in a pretrial discovery context.

Deciding the point for the first time, the Court held that Rule 143(g) sits within the trial rules and governs a party who calls an expert witness. No trial had taken place, and the declarations addressed pretrial procedure, not the section 482 merits.

It also objected that the declarations relied on protective orders from unrelated litigation, and maintained that its source code should be reviewed only in a clean room at its own or its counsel’s offices.

He sought a clean room in Austin, Texas, where his software expert is based, and a narrower category of information subject to clean room procedures.

Motions to strike are disfavoured and require both material unrelated to the controversy and prejudice; the taxpayer showed neither. The Court said it would disregard any legal opinion or advocacy when deciding the protective order motions, which remain pending.

The Tax Court denied the taxpayer’s motions to strike. Expert declarations filed in support of a pretrial discovery position are not expert reports under Rule 143(g). The section 482 merits and the clean room protective order remain to be decided.

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Transfer Pricing at Arm’s Length. Value Aligned, Globally Delivered.

  • Contact

  • +91 93609 91001

  • info@nexusprice.org

  • Willingdon Crescent, 4th Floor,#6/2, Dr. S.S.Badrinath Road, Nungambakkam, Chennai 600 006

©2025 NexusPrice. All rights reserved

©2025 NexusPrice. All rights reserved