“Dutch Acquisition Finance B.V.” (“the taxpayer”) was set up after an investment group’s 2017 leveraged buy-out of an international retail chain. It received equity and a EUR 140 million shareholder loan from a UK group finance company on terms mirroring the bank syndicate’s Facility B2 plus a 0.05% handling fee. It then bought a Dutch limited-risk retailer, remunerated at 9% of turnover, from a group company for EUR 233 million and formed a fiscal unity with it. The tax authority refused the interest deduction under Article 10a CITA.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The taxpayer contended that the debt was in substance owed to the third-party banks, as the shareholder loan mirrored the external bank facility (parallelism). | The tax authority denied the interest under Article 10a and the passed-on financing costs. It sought reversal of the burden of proof, as the return did not disclose reliance on the rebuttal rule. | The Court held that Article 10a(1) applied. The rebuttal failed: structuring documents showed a tax-driven push-down, and the loan lacked parallelism with the bank debt in term, repayment and interest payments. |
It submitted that the restructuring rested on commercial motives, notably more efficient cash flows to service the bank debt. The District Court had accepted these arguments. | It argued that the EUR 233 million price exceeded arm’s length value under Articles 8 and 8b, as the target had been valued as a full-risk entrepreneur. | The compensating levy test also failed and the burden of proof was reversed. The arm’s length issue was left undecided, as it would not change the outcome. |
The Court of Appeal set aside the District Court’s judgment and ruled for the tax authority, reducing the assessment only by a minor interest amount. On the facts, the shareholder loan was not sufficiently parallel to the bank debt for the banks to be regarded as the actual lenders.

