Mini Bakeries Uganda Limited (“the taxpayer”) manufactures and sells bakery products under the “SUPA LOAF” brand. It paid a royalty of 2% of net sales to Northgate Holdings Limited (NGHL), Mauritius, legal owner of the trademark, which had been assigned to NGHL in 2010 without disclosed consideration. Between 2018 and 2022 it also advanced unsecured USD loans of about USD 2.2 million to related entities in Kenya and Tanzania at 4.6% to 10%. After an audit of July 2015 to June 2023, the URA disallowed the royalty and increased the interest income.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The taxpayer contended that NGHL performed brand conceptualisation, strategic positioning and quality control, and that the 2% royalty was supported by a ktMINE-based CUP study. | The URA argued that NGHL performed none of the DEMPE functions and that legal ownership alone did not entitle it to a turnover-based royalty (OECD TPG Chapter VI). | The Tribunal found that the Trademark User Agreement placed all DEMPE obligations on the taxpayer, leaving NGHL with bare legal title. The documentation had no functional analysis, and the benchmarking was “performed in a vacuum”. |
On the loans, it argued that the URA’s method double-counted risk and exceeded market lending rates. It also sought a refund or credit of the WHT and VAT remitted on the royalty. | The URA priced the loans using a USD risk-free rate, the 4% lending risk premium in the taxpayer’s own documentation and a country risk premium for the borrowers’ jurisdictions. | On the loans, it rejected central bank deposit rates and secured bank facilities as comparables and noted that no options realistically available analysis existed. The WHT and VAT refund claims also failed. |
The Tribunal dismissed the application with costs and upheld the adjustments. On the facts, the royalty to an entity holding only legal title, with no DEMPE functions, was not supported by the benchmarking study relied upon.

