Samsung India Electronics Pvt. Ltd. (“the assessee”), a wholly owned subsidiary of Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Korea, manufactures and trades consumer electronics, home appliances, mobile phones and IT products and runs a networking division supplying telecom equipment. For AYs 2016-17 and 2017-18, the TPO treated AMP expenditure as an international transaction, benchmarked royalty under CUP at 1.50%, and rejected the Berry Ratio for the networking segment, aggregating its transactions under TNMM.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The assessee contended that there was no arrangement, understanding or action in concert obliging it to incur AMP expenditure for its parent, and that the royalty comparables were wholly dissimilar to its own arrangement. | The Revenue treated AMP spending as brand-promotion services rendered to the AE, applying the Bright Line Test and an intensity-based approach. It benchmarked royalty under CUP at 1.50% using three agreements from the agricultural and biotechnology sectors. | The Tribunal held that without an arrangement or action in concert, AMP is not a separate international transaction. The royalty comparables lacked similarity, and separate benchmarking after accepting TNMM was a double adjustment. |
For the networking segment, the assessee submitted that it acted as a low-risk merchanting distributor holding only flash title, and that the Berry Ratio and segregated benchmarking were therefore appropriate. | The Revenue rejected the Berry Ratio and segregated benchmarking, aggregating equipment imports and support services under TNMM with service-sector comparables. | The Tribunal excluded Verizon Communications and other service companies as functionally different from a largely trading business. It upheld segregated benchmarking and the Berry Ratio, as cost of goods sold was a mere pass-through cost. |
Delhi ITAT allowed both appeals, deleting the AMP, royalty and expatriate salary adjustments. The Berry Ratio was accepted for the low-risk distribution transaction, and separate royalty benchmarking after TNMM had been accepted for the manufacturing segment was held to be a double adjustment.

