Inventec (Czech), s. r. o. (“the taxpayer”), wholly owned by Inventec Corp., Taiwan, bought production materials from its parent in 2015 and manufactured server cabinets that the parent sold to Hewlett-Packard. Both sides applied a net margin method. The Specialised Tax Office tested the result on Return on Total Costs (ROTC), attributing to the taxpayer 24.62% of the functions and risks linked to materials and applying a reduced material mark-up. Additional corporate income tax of CZK 28,250,530 and a penalty were assessed.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions |
|---|---|
The taxpayer contended that ROVAC, which excludes material costs, was the correct indicator for a contract manufacturer. Its ownership of the materials was merely formal, and it lacked the financial capacity to bear material-related risks (OECD TPG para 1.64). | The tax authority accepted that the taxpayer was not a fully fledged manufacturer, but found that it performed material-related functions and bore some material risks, so that ROTC was the appropriate indicator. |
It argued that the denominator should exclude controlled transactions (para 2.94), that the size of the adjustment showed an unreliable result (para 3.51), and that acceptance of ROVAC in RR Donnelley gave it a legitimate expectation. | It applied a reduced material mark-up based on the 24.62% share of functions and risks, in order to improve comparability with the independent companies selected. |
Court's Judgment:
The Court held that the choice of testing approach lies with the tax authority where it rests on objective criteria and is convincingly reasoned. ROTC was neither arbitrary nor unverifiable, as the taxpayer stored, handled, tested and assembled the materials and bore limited material-related risks.
The OECD Guidelines and Guideline D-34 are soft law and permit comparability adjustments. The legitimate expectation plea failed: one divergent treatment is not settled practice, and in RR Donnelley the taxpayer owned only 10.5% of the materials used.
The Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the cassation appeal and upheld the assessment. On the facts, the taxpayer owned the materials and performed material-related functions, so ROTC with a reduced material mark-up reflecting its limited functions and risks was accepted.

