Delmonte Kenya Limited (“the taxpayer”), engaged in growing and processing pineapples and selling juices and food products, sold fresh and processed pineapples to its Swiss related party, Del Monte International GmbH. For 2019 to 2021, the KRA rejected its TNMM analysis, applied a customs-based deductive approach and disallowed recharges and loan interest, making a primary adjustment of KES 10,602,764,502. It then treated that amount as a deemed dividend to non-resident related parties and assessed withholding tax.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The taxpayer contended that the withholding tax assessment was premature, as the primary TP dispute was pending and no dividend had been declared or paid. Under OECD TPG para 4.68, a secondary adjustment presupposes a final primary adjustment. | The KRA’s position, as reflected in the decision, was that Section 7(1)(b)(v) deems the adjusted amount to be a dividend once the primary adjustment is made, with the due date set at 20 December 2024, the date of that adjustment. | The Tribunal held that Section 7(1)(b)(v) is a mandatory deeming provision triggered by the primary adjustment itself, not by its judicial confirmation. The underlying appeal had in any case been decided for the KRA in January 2026. |
It argued that a contested secondary adjustment is a parallel assessment needing its own basis, and that issuing it during the appeal breached its right to fair administrative action under Articles 47 and 50 of the Constitution. | The KRA treated the secondary adjustment as consequential on the primary one. The record showed it had issued the assessment, stated its basis, allowed the objection and given a reasoned decision. | The two adjustments operate in different legal dimensions; the second is consequential, not parallel. No breach of Article 47 was shown, and the burden under Section 56(1) of the Tax Procedures Act was not discharged. |
The Tribunal dismissed the appeal and upheld the objection decision in full. It held that a deemed dividend under Section 7(1)(b)(v) arises when the primary TP adjustment is made, so the withholding tax assessment was not premature although the primary adjustment was under appeal.

