The case: In Roquette India Pvt. Ltd., the TPO set the arm's length price of intra-group services at nil because he saw too little benefit.
The ruling: The Tribunal deleted an adjustment of about Rs. 24.37 crore for AY 2017-18, and a similar amount for AY 2018-19. A subjective benefit test cannot replace a prescribed method. The linked section 37(1) disallowance also fell once the TP adjustment went.
Evidence that the services were received remains the taxpayer's best defence against a nil ALP.

