The case: In Bellsonica Auto Component India Pvt. Ltd. (ITA No. 1049/Del/2023, AY 2014-15, decided 17 June 2026), the TPO cut the arm's length royalty paid to the foreign AE to nil.
The ruling: The Tribunal said TP analysis should follow the principles of the taxpayer's unilateral APA. That APA, dated 29 November 2022, accepted 1.9% of net sales for royalty and technical services, and the Tribunal limited the adjustment to that rate. A domestic manufacturing adjustment was deleted, following Karnataka High Court authority.
An APA can help a taxpayer even in years it does not cover.

