The case: In an order of 10 June 2026, the Tribunal gave relief to chemical maker Gulbrandsen Pvt. Ltd. on major TP additions.
The ruling: Where facts do not change across years, the tax authority should apply the same TP method. TNMM, accepted earlier, was upheld. The deletion of additions on sales promotion and marketing services received from overseas AEs was also upheld.
Keeping functions, contracts and methods consistent from year to year gives taxpayers the rule of consistency as a defence.

