Vodafone Idea Limited (“the assessee”), successor to Vodafone Mobile Services Limited, is a telecommunications company. For AY 2015-16 it paid a brand royalty of 1.75% of net service revenue to its AE, Vodafone Sales and Services Ltd., and interest to AEs on external commercial borrowings (ECBs) at the RBI-approved all-in-cost ceilings. The TPO rejected its CUP comparables, which averaged 2.67%, and set the royalty at 0.25% of gross sales based on a Virgin Enterprises–Virgin Mobile USA agreement. It also adjusted the ECB interest and AMP expenditure.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The assessee contended that CUP requires uncontrolled transactions, whereas the Virgin agreement was itself controlled. Its own comparables averaged 2.67%. | The TPO rejected the assessee’s comparables and relied on the Virgin Enterprises–Virgin Mobile USA agreement to fix the royalty at 0.25% of gross sales. | The Tribunal held that a controlled transaction cannot be a valid CUP comparable and that the ALP must follow Rule 10B. The royalty adjustment was deleted. |
It submitted that RBI-approved rates were a reliable benchmark for ECB interest, and that AMP is not an international transaction without an arrangement with the AEs. | The TPO rejected the RBI approvals as a CUP and used its own comparables. Applying BLT, it treated excess AMP spend as brand-building services to the AEs. | Following Vodafone West Ltd., the RBI all-in-cost was a highly relevant benchmark; the TPO’s comparables lacked risk and tenure adjustments. The AMP adjustment was also deleted. |
The Tribunal partly allowed the appeal, deleting the brand royalty, ECB interest and AMP adjustments. A controlled agreement was held not to be a valid CUP, and the RBI-approved all-in-cost was treated as a highly relevant, though not conclusive, benchmark for ECB interest.

