• Transactions

    Employee threshold

    Turnover threshold

    Economic adjustment

    Global Tax

    Hard-to-Value Intangibles (HTVI)

    OECD Framework

    Multinational Enterprises (MNEs)

    APMA

    APA

ITAT: Controlled Agreement Not a Valid CUP for Brand Royalty; ECB Interest and AMP Adjustments Deleted

ITAT: Controlled Agreement Not a Valid CUP for Brand Royalty; ECB Interest and AMP Adjustments Deleted

ITAT: Controlled Agreement Not a Valid CUP for Brand Royalty; ECB Interest and AMP Adjustments Deleted

Vodafone Idea Limited (“the assessee”), successor to Vodafone Mobile Services Limited, is a telecommunications company. For AY 2015-16 it paid a brand royalty of 1.75% of net service revenue to its AE, Vodafone Sales and Services Ltd., and interest to AEs on external commercial borrowings (ECBs) at the RBI-approved all-in-cost ceilings. The TPO rejected its CUP comparables, which averaged 2.67%, and set the royalty at 0.25% of gross sales based on a Virgin Enterprises–Virgin Mobile USA agreement. It also adjusted the ECB interest and AMP expenditure.

Assessee’s Contentions

Revenue’s Contentions

Court’s Judgement

The assessee contended that CUP requires uncontrolled transactions, whereas the Virgin agreement was itself controlled. Its own comparables averaged 2.67%.

The TPO rejected the assessee’s comparables and relied on the Virgin Enterprises–Virgin Mobile USA agreement to fix the royalty at 0.25% of gross sales.

The Tribunal held that a controlled transaction cannot be a valid CUP comparable and that the ALP must follow Rule 10B. The royalty adjustment was deleted.

It submitted that RBI-approved rates were a reliable benchmark for ECB interest, and that AMP is not an international transaction without an arrangement with the AEs.

The TPO rejected the RBI approvals as a CUP and used its own comparables. Applying BLT, it treated excess AMP spend as brand-building services to the AEs.

Following Vodafone West Ltd., the RBI all-in-cost was a highly relevant benchmark; the TPO’s comparables lacked risk and tenure adjustments. The AMP adjustment was also deleted.

The Tribunal partly allowed the appeal, deleting the brand royalty, ECB interest and AMP adjustments. A controlled agreement was held not to be a valid CUP, and the RBI-approved all-in-cost was treated as a highly relevant, though not conclusive, benchmark for ECB interest.

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Transfer Pricing at Arm’s Length. Value Aligned, Globally Delivered.

  • Contact

  • +91 93609 91001

  • info@nexusprice.org

  • Willingdon Crescent, 4th Floor,#6/2, Dr. S.S.Badrinath Road, Nungambakkam, Chennai 600 006

©2025 NexusPrice. All rights reserved

©2025 NexusPrice. All rights reserved