Minor International (Labuan) Limited (“the taxpayer”), part of the Minor International hotel and hospitality group and taxable in the Maldives under the Business Profit Tax Act (BPTA), claimed interest for 2018 on two advances from its parent, Minor International Public Company Limited, and from MHG International Holding (Mauritius) Limited. It also claimed interest on a further USD 1,150,000 loan from the parent used to settle additional tax from earlier audits. MIRA treated the two advances as equity contributions and disallowed all the interest.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The taxpayer argued that MIRA never disputed that the funds were borrowed to produce income, carried out no comparability analysis or benchmarking, and could not infer non-arm’s length terms from related-party status alone. | MIRA found that the two advances lacked the features of bona fide loans: no effective repayment mechanism, no repayment of the parent loan despite its stated maturity, no security and a thin capital structure. | The Tribunal held that a comparability analysis is inherent in the arm’s length standard. The transaction must first be accurately delineated (OECD TPG para 1.33); where the advance is not a loan, no benchmarking is needed. |
It relied on its audited financial statements, which recorded the funds as debt, and pleaded legitimate expectation and equal treatment because the same interest deduction had been allowed in an earlier audit. | It treated the advances as equity, disallowing interest under s. 11(a)(5) and invoking s. 29(g) BPTA. Interest on the USD 1,150,000 loan was refused under s. 10(a) as not incurred wholly and exclusively to produce income. | The absence of repayment, repayment terms and security supported treatment as equity. Interest on the loan used to pay tax failed the wholly and exclusively test, and legitimate expectation was rejected. |
The Tribunal unanimously dismissed the appeal and upheld MIRA’s decision. It held that accurate delineation comes before pricing; as the advances had no repayment mechanism, security or actual repayment, they were treated as equity and no benchmarking was required.

