• Transactions

    Employee threshold

    Turnover threshold

    Economic adjustment

    Global Tax

    Hard-to-Value Intangibles (HTVI)

    OECD Framework

    Multinational Enterprises (MNEs)

    APMA

    APA

Italy Supreme Court: Cost-Plus Method Upheld; CUP Enjoys No Strict Priority over Other Methods

Italy Supreme Court: Cost-Plus Method Upheld; CUP Enjoys No Strict Priority over Other Methods

Italy Supreme Court: Cost-Plus Method Upheld; CUP Enjoys No Strict Priority over Other Methods

Montebianco S.p.A. (“the taxpayer”), an Italian gelato and pastry group, made intra-group sales to its US subsidiary, Montebianco USA, and determined their arm’s length value under the cost-plus method. The US subsidiary bore significant personnel costs for its own staff, unlike other markets where the Italian parent bore such costs directly. The Revenue Agency issued assessment notices under Article 110(7) of the TUIR, contending that the CUP method should have been used. The Regional Tax Commission ruled for the taxpayer, and the Agency appealed.

Assessee’s Contentions

Revenue’s Contentions

Court’s Judgement

The taxpayer contended that cost-plus was a legitimate method, adapted to the specific features of the case, in particular the personnel costs borne by Montebianco USA.

The Revenue Agency argued that the judgment under appeal was void for lack of reasoning and that the Commission had wrongly upheld the taxpayer’s method.

The Court held that CUP retains an implicit preference but does not bar cost-plus where appropriate. The strict hierarchy of the 1995 OECD Guidelines was removed in 2010.

Those costs distinguished the US market from markets where the Italian parent bore them, and it had validly shown that the controlled sales reflected arm’s length value.

It maintained that the taxpayer had not discharged its burden of proof and that the CUP method was the correct approach.

The Commission had adequately explained why cost-plus suited the case, notably the US subsidiary’s personnel costs, and the taxpayer had proved arm’s length value.

The Supreme Court rejected the Revenue Agency’s appeal on the transfer pricing issue and referred the case back to the Lombardy Regional Tax Court of Appeal. CUP retains an implicit preference, but the reasoned cost-plus analysis adapted to the facts was upheld.

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Ready to Elevate Your Brand?

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Let’s team up and turn your vision into results.

Transfer Pricing at Arm’s Length. Value Aligned, Globally Delivered.

  • Contact

  • +91 93609 91001

  • info@nexusprice.org

  • Willingdon Crescent, 4th Floor,#6/2, Dr. S.S.Badrinath Road, Nungambakkam, Chennai 600 006

©2025 NexusPrice. All rights reserved

©2025 NexusPrice. All rights reserved