TotalEnergies EP Norge AS (“the taxpayer”), a Total Group subsidiary producing oil and gas on the Norwegian continental shelf and taxed at a combined 78%, sold dry gas on a short-term basis to its UK sister company, TotalEnergies Gas & Power Ltd. (TGP). For 2014 to 2017 there were about 1,800 transactions under a 2002 framework agreement, worth roughly NOK 7.8 billion. The Oil Tax Office held that the pricing ignored the flexibility and preferential access TGP enjoyed and, applying CUP, added EUR 0.55 per MWh, increasing income by NOK 217 million.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The taxpayer contended that the sales involved standardised products priced against hub reference prices (index or closing prices), and were therefore equivalent to sales to independent parties. | The Oil Tax Office held that the pricing did not reflect the value of the flexibility and preferential access enjoyed by TGP, for which independent parties would have paid a separate premium. | The Court assessed the roughly 1,800 transactions collectively: TGP in practice obtained stable access to the taxpayer’s short-term volumes and security of supply. Documentation gaps weighed against the taxpayer, and a reduction of income was proven. |
It submitted that no flexibility was transferred to TGP and that TGP’s realistically available alternatives had to be considered under a two-sided CUP analysis. | Applying CUP, it benchmarked the sales against independent volume-flexible agreements and fixed a flexibility value of EUR 0.55 per MWh, raising income subject to special petroleum tax by NOK 217 million. | However, the volume-flexible medium-term agreements used as comparables priced a different type of benefit and risk than fixed-volume intra-group deliveries, so the discretionary assessment rested on an incorrect application of the law. |
The Court of Appeal dismissed the State’s appeal and set aside the Oil Tax Office’s decision, though for reasons other than the taxpayer’s main argument. A reduction of income was found, but the comparables used priced a different type of benefit and risk.

