Suzuki Motorcycle India Pvt Ltd (“the assessee”), the Indian subsidiary of the Suzuki group, incurred Advertising, Marketing and Promotion (AMP) expenditure. The Revenue applied the Bright Line Test (BLT), comparing its AMP spend with that of comparable independent entities and treating the excess as incurred to promote the brand of the foreign AE. The ITAT rejected the AMP adjustment, relying on the Delhi High Court decisions in Sony Ericsson and Maruti Suzuki. The Revenue appealed under Section 260A (ITA 188/2025 and ITA 191/2025).
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The assessee submitted that the High Court has repeatedly held that the Bright Line Test is not a method sanctioned by law for making an AMP adjustment. | The Revenue contended that the ITAT was not justified in rejecting the adjustment merely by relying on Sony Ericsson and Maruti Suzuki. | The High Court followed its precedents in Sony Ericsson and Maruti Suzuki and reaffirmed that the Bright Line Test is not a method sanctioned by law for an AMP-related adjustment, despite the issue pending before the Supreme Court. |
It pointed out that the Supreme Court had rejected the special leave petition in Whirlpool of India in November 2024, which supported its position. | It submitted that the underlying issues are pending before the Supreme Court, including whether incurring AMP expenditure itself gives rise to an international transaction. | The Revenue need not file separate appeals. If the Supreme Court allows the pending matters in Sony Ericsson and Maruti Suzuki, the law so declared will apply to the assessee’s case as well. |
Delhi HC dismissed the Revenue’s appeals and the AMP adjustment remains deleted, following its precedents that the Bright Line Test is not a method sanctioned by law. The outcome remains subject to the Supreme Court’s decision in Sony Ericsson and Maruti Suzuki.

