Facebook, Inc. and Subsidiaries (“the taxpayer”) entered into a cost sharing arrangement (CSA) with Facebook Ireland on 15 September 2010. Facebook Ireland had to make a platform contribution transaction (PCT) payment for the platform technology, the user base and marketing intangibles. The Tax Court had earlier held the income method to be the best method and valued the contributions in aggregate. The parties could not agree the Rule 155 computations, including how to convert the PCT value into contingent annual royalties.
Assessee’s Contentions | Revenue’s Contentions | Court’s Judgement |
The taxpayer primarily argued that the royalties it had already reported should be increased proportionally. | The IRS argued that the PCT licence agreements did not specify the royalty base and period, and that the Ernst & Young documentation could not be used as its valuation methodology had been rejected. | The Court held that a CSA must state the form of payment, but the royalty base and periods may be set out in contemporaneous CSA documentation, whose payment methodology remains usable. |
Alternatively, it relied on its contemporaneous CSA documentation: technology royalties over about four years, user community royalties over about six years on a declining base, and a perpetual 1% trademark royalty. | It proposed a single aggregate flat-rate royalty on rest-of-world revenue over 6.29 years. | Neither the 6.29-year flat-rate royalty nor a proportional increase reflected the parties’ actual conduct and risk allocation. The Court applied three royalty streams, a 70/30 revenue split and a 17.7% discount rate. |
The Tax Court ruled largely for the taxpayer on the remaining computations. A PCT payment may be converted into contingent royalties using the payment structure in contemporaneous CSA documentation, with the greatest weight given to the parties’ actual conduct.

